
Sonic Youth
Rather Ripped
(Geffen; 2006)
I’ve always had this theory about the Youth and the world of “cooler-than-thou” hipsterdom. In fact I’ve been known to call it the “SY Postulate of Indie Music” (I’ve also been known to use nipple clamps and anal beads, so take that as you will). It basically states that once a band reaches the “Critical Mass of “Cool” a few very important things happen. Among these are that the people stop holding the band to any sort of reasonable standards. In other words anything/everything they do is likened unto True Art by those that Understand True Art. If Radiohead releases a bluegrass album next year, most cool people will acknowledge that it is truly Pushing the Boundaries of Art even if it is complete and utter shit. Perhaps more interestingly, when a band reaches the CMoC people start buying their records to make their record collections look cool. It’s like adding a piece of expensive art to your living room. You don’t “get” it; in fact, you don’t even like it. You think it looks like two slinkies having hot, nasty slinky-sex. But it makes you look damn cool to all your friends.
If there’s one thing we can all agree on, it’s that Sonic Youth are basically the coolest thing in music. All you have to do is talk about how you’ve worn out you Daydream Nation vinyl record from all those afternoons trying to wrap your head around the 6 minutes of feedback on “The Sprawl”, or how Sister is the best self-released album ever made in order to score yourself some huge hipster points. Fans and critics know they’re cool. The band knows they’re cool. I owned Daydream Nation for two years before I ever made it past the second song. I didn’t actually have to listen to the record. It made me hip just by owning it.
In part because of their efforts to protect their undisputed coolness (whether conscious or not), Sonic Youth has always been one of the most frustrating bands for me to listen to. While on each of their albums there are numerous moments of sheer pop brilliance or focused guitar work, they seem to feel more comfortable when they are blasting mind-numbing feedback or indulging their talents in fretboard wank-fests. All this leads me to my point: Rather Ripped is their least “cool” album; not surprisingly, it also makes it the most listenable SY album to date. Die-hard Sonic Youth fans will hate this album: there is much more of a focus of melody (both in voice and guitar), conventional song-structure, and almost no traces of extended jam sessions.
“Reena” kicks off the solid first three songs of Ripped with Kim Gordon’s best Nico impression. Under a driving bass line and focused guitar work, Gordon relates a cryptic message of devotion to her husband (“you keep me coming home again”) despite the best efforts of a rather special female “friend”. Rather than aprubtly abandoning a straightforward rock song for a wash of feedback and dissonant solos, the band is content to be focused on keeping their pop gems to a easily digestible length. Gordon has always been the Youth’s secret weapon: typically her unique vocal style takes precedence over Thurston Moore’s spaz-rock solo adventures, which allows songs to progress at a better pace.
The single “Incinerate” is the highlight of the album. With it’s Broken Social Scene lyrics/delivery and blissful little guitar melody that sings more than it snarls, “Incinerate” is an example of how a great rock song can be well-sculpted and fun at the same time (!). You can almost see the band, tongues wagging and V-kicking on stage, enjoying the 4/4 rocker as much as the crowd. And, perhaps more amazingly, the lyrics are not head-slappingly moronic: “I ripped your heart out from your chest/Replaced it with a grenade blast/…You douse my soul in gasoline/ Flick a match into my brain.” (Let’s not kid ourselves: SY has never been that concerned about lyrics and it will always be their weakest aspect. On Rather Ripped, they are at least giving it a second thought.) No less impressive is the beautifully stark and delicate “Do You Believe in Rapture?”. Slow harmonics strums and a drum machine sets the atmosphere for a rare glimpse into the band’s personal side. This is the band at its finest, splitting the difference between pop perfection and art-rock noise in a way that is surprisingly successful.
Gordon makes good use of her other lead vocal appearances with “Jams Run Free” and “The Neutral”. The first is actually quite the misnomer; it is a carefully crafted work between bass and guitar that breaks in the middle for two dueling fuzz-solos that seem rather well rehearsed, and the second is a pristine, almost spectral reverbed number that wouldn’t seem out of place on a Clientele album. Both songs are clearly concious efforts to stay within the “I-can-still-sing-along-to-this” range, as opposed to going into atmospheric guitar freak-out world. Sometimes it seems a little forced. If you ever listened to a Sonic Youth record before, you know they can’t continue with a “pop song” for more than 2 minutes without itching to break out the distortion pedals. There are times on the record where you can almost picture guitarist Thurston Moore tapping his foot impatiently like a 8 year old, asking his wife Gordon, “Can I play with the effects pedals yet? Pleeeese? I wanna play weird sounds!” and Kim just shaking her head like a disapproving mother.
But here’s the rub: when they do play the Dissonance, Feedback, Weird Guitar Sounds Game, they do it very subtly, as if they are indulging in a forbidden act. More than often it the type of noise rock that is more readily accepted by the casual listener. In fact, it sort of reminds me of Perfect From Now On, Built to Spill’s 1996 masterpiece. Don’t get me wrong, this album is nowhere near the caliber of Perfect, but it does indulge in some feedback/abstract guitar work that contrasts nicely with the hummable and catchy tunes on either side of the atmospheric fuzz. This might have something to do with the exodus of producer/guitarist Jim O’Rourke who (in my humble opinion) completely fucked up the band while he was a member, focusing way too much on artistic masturbation and the Wall of Sound and spending less time on the songs themselves. Ultimately this album is a conscious effort at making “pop songs” while showing restraint with the quirks that make the band so beloved in many circles.
Unfortunately not all of Rather Ripped is successful in this goal. “Turquoise Boy”, while not unpleasant, seems lacking direction and quite dull, and album closer “Or” falls prey to the same issues. In general the last part of the album loses a little bit of the steam that the first two thirds of the album worked so hard to build up. Also, there are no barn-burning, four-to-the-floor rockers in the last half of the album which tracks like “Incinerate” make you want to hear more of. Also, the lyrics: I’m sorry, some of them just don’t it for me.
But let me say this: the Youth have made a record that I can get through the whole way, every time. You have no idea how incredibly shocking that is for me. It seems like they stopped trying to impress people with their ability to make “unlistenable” records and make one that was palatable for the majority of indie rockers. Guitarist Thurston Moore said in an interview that the increase in popularity of noise-rock in the last few years was as good an excuse as any to make a “pop” record. I found myself chuckling when I heard that. I guess SY will never relinquish that relished role of staying ahead of the “cool” curve. At least with Rather Ripped they have made a record that the casual, un-cool Sonic Youth fan (like me) can enjoy rocking out to on a summer evening.
*Check out the video for “Incinerate” at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LCpjtYqpWp8